When are IT pros going to stop sabotaging worker productivity?
For years, I’ve heard employees in my productivity seminars complaining about their IT departments. Some of these complaints I believe have valid justifications, and I stick up for IT:
COMPLAINT: IT won’t let them load personal software.
JUSTIFIED! Doing so would create a staffing nightmare as workers seek help on non-supported applications. Could also create security concerns and open the door to system viruses.
COMPLAINT: IT restricts access to certain Internet sites
JUSTIFIED! I can’t think of a good reason why employees would need to watch X-rated videos at work.
COMPLAINT: IT doesn’t upgrade their operating systems and software to the newest version for years after the release.
JUSTIFIED! You don’t need new technology for the sake of new technology. There must be a cost-benefit analysis to determine if the new features will boost performance and productivity, commensure to the level of staff support IT is able to provide.
BUT many of the things IT does are ridiculous and I just don’t understand. For example:
COMPLAINT: IT has removed my desktop printer, and I have to walk down the hall to the printer.
NOT JUSTIFIED! This is the most ridiculous thing I’ve heard of in a while. Holy cow, I print continually. Even electronic/PDA/Blackberry types still have piles of paper all over their desks. It’s crazy to think about how much people make per hour times the number of employees in an organization, all walking down the hall to the shared printer, where of course they’re likely to stumble into Chatty Suzy, who wants to tell you about her nightcrawlers. You get to the printer—CRAP!—it didn’t print out, someone took it, it’s not what I thought, margins are cut off, etc., BACK to the office to print again. I don’t care squat about how hard it is to service all those printers. Get a contractor to handle it. Printers are cheap. The cost of not having a printer on the desk top of every employee is a huge productivity and profitability drain.
COMPLAINT: My company won’t purchase a Blackberry/Treo/Smartphone for me to use.
NOT JUSTIFIED: I know most people would be far more productive if they had instant access to their email, calendar, and contacts from anywhere. I feel so sorry for people who are forced to print out their Outlook info, schlep it home, write on it manually, carry it back to work, and update it again, just to keep things organized. Employees tend to stay connected at home if they have a device. I tell people who complain about their companies not buying them a Blackberry to suck it up and buy one themselves! But then at http://www.itbusiness.ca/it/client/en/home/News.asp?id=39533&cid=5 a consortium of CIOs actually came up with some "best practices" for managing PDAs. They suggest "Don’t allow the connection of privately owned PDAs to your corporate network. There will also be an issue with having proper back-ups and generally adhering to standards." So you’re actually suggesting that people who dip into their own pockets to buy a device to aid their productivity and increase the profitability of the organization shouldn’t be allowed to do so? Hello IT!! Why don’t you get with all the managers and mandate they buy people one who want one, so people don’t have to connect with a privately-owned device? You are out of touch with the business reality of what many workers are dealing with.
COMPLAINT: I’m not allowed to load personal information on my Outlook.
NOT JUSTIFIED! People don’t simply turn off their private lives when they walk through your doors, and they don’t stop thinking about work at home, either. You can’t have it both ways! Do you actually expect for them to maintain two completely unrelated systems, rending their time management ability totally useless? If your system doesn’t incorporate both your personal and professional lives, you are setting yourself up for conflicts and inefficiencies, which will ultimately affect a worker’s performance on the job. This artcicle suggests IT should "Establish clear policies on PDA use, targeting items such as business versus personal use, playing games, downloading inappropriate material or using it to share family pictures." Get a clue!!! Do you think people are robots? That they’re going to come to work and not think about their families again? Socializing and water cooler chat are important for relationship building and is not simply a waste of time. Connecting with co-workers on a personal level builds trust and comraderie that’s essential in building the support you need to get things done quickly.
COMPLAINT: My company makes me carry a Blackberry to check my email, but they said the phone service is too expensive, so I have to use a different cell phone, and I’m still required to wear my pager for emergencies?
JUSTIFICATION: None necessary, you can figure this one out on your own the first time you see some poor sap with three different devices strapped to his/her waist.
DO I HEAR AN ‘AMEN’?





